Home > Orthopedics and Beyond > Collection Highlights > World War I

Orthopedics and Beyond:

Highlights from the H. Winnett Orr Collection

World War I

Shortly after the United States’s entry into WWI, H. Winnett Orr, MD, was invited to join the Goldthwait Unit of Orthopedic Surgeons traveling to England at the request of Sir Robert Jones, who established specialized orthopedic wards for injured soldiers, to assist in British orthopedic hospitals. Dr. Orr was commissioned a captain on May 18, 1917, and served two years in England, Wales and France. He was discharged at the rank of lieutenant colonel on June 1, 1919. During his service, he revitalized Hugh Owen Thomas’s rest method of treatment for open fractures. Dr. Orr’s inclusion of plaster to reinforce immobilization and rest became known as the “Orr Method.”

The treatment of war wounds

William W. Keen (1837-1932)
Orr No. 1375
1917
 
“Lister taught us, above all, how to prevent infection; Dakin and Carrel, following Lister’s principles, have taught us how to conquer even rampant infection. For nearly half a century, we surgeons have been fighting firmly intrenched infection, but always in vain. It required the stern stimulus of war to enable us to win the victory. Prevention and cure both are now ours.” (p. 75) “It is, and has been my feeling, of course, that this and many other early estimates of the Carrel-Dakin method were over-enthusiastic. As early as 1918, I felt that the Carrel-Dakin method involved too much disturbance of splints and casts in compound fractures, and by 1921, I had declared against this and all other frequent dressing methods in wound infection.”
 

Annotation by H. Winnett Orr from A catalogue of the H. Winnett Orr historical collection and other rare books in the library of the American College of Surgeons (1960).

 

William W. Keen, MD, served as an army surgeon in both the American Civil War and WWI. During the Civil War, Dr. Keen developed an interest in nervous system injuries. His documentation of these injuries is considered the beginning of American neurology. He was the first American surgeon to successfully remove a benign brain tumor in 1887. Dr. Keen attended Joseph Lister’s presentation on antisepsis in surgery in Philadelphia in 1876 and became one of the first surgeons in the United States to adopt Lister’s antiseptic practices. In 1893, he led a team of doctors to remove a large oral lesion from President Grover Cleveland’s palate in secrecy. Dr. Keen served as a major in the Medical Reserve Corps in WWI.

image file Keen03

The treatment of war wounds, 1917

Image of the Balkan splint used by American in France during WWI

Top

 

Wounds and fractures: a clinical guide to civil and military practice

H. Winnett Orr
Orr No. 1209
1941
 

In his book, Wounds and fractures: a clinical guide to civil and military practice, Dr. Orr presented fracture treatments, including reduction, splinting, plaster of Paris, skeletal fixation, methods of avoiding wound infection and operative treatments. The Orr method, his plaster of Paris with infrequent dress technique, is also featured in the book. Dr. Orr included a supportive quote from a fellow orthopedic surgeon: “Orr has splendidly understood, that after Lister the history of wound treatment is working in the same direction, concurring to the development of Lister’s ideas of physical antiseptics; drainage, rest, protection of wounds from irritation, immobilization…The influence of the Orr method on the patient’s general condition is astounding.”

Top

 

An orthopedic surgeon’s story of the Great War

H. Winnett Orr
Orr No. 1416
1921
 

During WWI, Dr. Orr was stationed with the Army Medical Department in England and France as an orthopedic surgeon. He wrote about his experiences and observations from working in military hospitals. In An orthopedic surgeon’s story of the Great War, he described leaving the United States, the journey to and arrival in Europe, the program at the hospitals and the individuals he met (including Sir William Osler, MD) and an English Christmas.

 

“It became my duty to decide whether the wounded, upon arrival in Savenay [France], were suitable for immediate transfer to the United States or whether they should be detained for splints, the correction of deformities, further surgical treatment, or even amputation.”

 

Excerpt from An orthopedic surgeon’s story of the Great War

Top

 

The treatment of infected wounds

Alexis Carrel (1873-1944)
Orr No. 760
1917

 

Alexis Carrel, MD, was a French physician who won the 1912 Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine for his work on anastomosing arteries and veins and the suturing of vessels. He also was interested in organ transplantation, which he researched at the Rockefeller Institute in New York. During WWI, the institute provided $20,000 to set up a hospital at Compiegne in France. Dr. Carrel and Henry Dakin collaborated on a wound management system, the Carrel-Dakin method, which involved cleansing wounds with Dakin’s solution and proper debridement of dead tissue. Before antibiotics, the technique improved patient outcomes.

 

“As a result of my experience in the war hospitals of England and France I became a critic of the Carrel-Dakin method as introduced at that time. There was too much disturbance of splints and casts; too much irrigating; too many dressings; and altogether so much disturbance of the wound and the patient that wound complications which delayed healing were the rule rather than the exception. It is a fact, that when properly employed, the Carrel-Dakin method has been one of the best methods for the antiseptic cleansing of wounds. Undoubtedly lives and limbs were saved by this method. On the other hand, recovery was often postponed, and a certain number of wound complications and secondary metastases of infection occurred because of the wound drainage and disturbance of injured parts involved in this plan of treatment.”

 

Annotation by H. Winnett Orr from A catalogue of the H. Winnett Orr historical collection and other rare books in the library of the American College of Surgeons (1960).

image file Carrell03

The treatment of infected wounds, 1917

Image of a compound fracture of the tibia with a drainage tube

Top