Home > Orthopedics and Beyond > Collection Highlights >Dickens

Orthopedics and Beyond:

Highlights from the H. Winnett Orr Collection

The Works of Charles Dickens

While most of Dr. Orr's collection related to medicine, he also collected books by famous literary figures, including novels, poetry and literary criticism. Books of the literary genre were inspired by Dr. Orr’s friend and medical school classmate, Mary McKibbin-Harper, MD. One of Dr. McKibbin-Harper’s literary interests was the works of Charles Dickens. She founded the Chicago, Pittsburgh and Berkeley branches of the Charles Dickens Fellowship.

Charles Dickens is one of the most famous novelists of the 19th century. A British author, Dickens was interested in observing humanity, particularly its diseases and illnesses. His novels feature characters with unique symptomology and clinical descriptions that physicians of his time did not recognize. Dickens worked to bring social awareness about children in poverty, those suffering from illnesses, and those working in dangerous occupations.

Mr. Pickwick’s pilgrimages

Walter Dexter
Orr No. 2198
1927
“Dr. McKibbin-Harper had founded the Dickens Fellowship in the United States. She knew the author and ‘rambled in London’ with him several times.”

Annotation by H. Winnett Orr from A catalogue of the H. Winnett Orr historical collection and other rare books in the library of the American College of Surgeons (1960).

The Posthumous papers of the Pickwick club, known as The Pickwick papers, was Charles Dickens' first novel. In the novel, Samuel Pickwick is the founder and president of the Pickwick Club and he and the club members travel to different locales in the English countryside.

Dickens created a character in The Pickwick papers named Joe, whom medical experts today diagnose as having suffered from obesity hypoventilation syndrome (OHS), a condition not recognized until the 20th century. Patients with OHS do not breathe rapidly or deeply enough, lowering oxygen levels in their blood and raising carbon dioxide levels. OHS patients also often develop sleep apnea, which fits with Dickens’ description of Joe often falling asleep.

image file Dexter02

Mr. Pickwick’s pilgrimages, 1927

Image of “Christmas Eve at Dingley Dell”

image file Dexter03

Mr. Pickwick’s pilgrimages, 1927

Image of “The Skating Party at Dingley Dell”

Top

 

The London of Charles Dickens:

being an account of the haunts of his characters and the topographical settings of his novels

E. Beresford Chancellor
Orr No. 2195

London during Charles Dickens' time was overcrowded, with nearly 2.5 million inhabitants sharing the city with draft animals. The public trash collection and sewer systems were inadequate. Difficult working conditions and poverty fueled Dickens’ interest in public health and his interest in the plight of children. Characters like Tiny Tim from A Christmas carol were reminders to readers of London’s impoverished and ill children. London did not have separate wards or hospitals for children as the separate medical specialty of pediatrics did not exist until the late 19th century. Still, Dickens lobbied for public funding to establish a hospital dedicated to children. The Great Ormond Street Hospital opened in 1852, and Dickens supported the facility, raising money for it through public readings of his works, and a ward was named for him. The hospital appears in one of his novels, Our mutual friend.

Top

 

The Works of Charles Dickens

Charles Dickens
Orr No. 2194
6 volumes>

Tiny Tim, from A Christmas carol, is one of Charles Dickens’ most recognizable characters and scholars, especially medical doctors, have attempted to diagnose his condition for many years. Tiny Tim was described by Dickens as wearing leg braces and using a crutch, and stated that Scrooge’s financial assistance could save Tim’s life.

Some scholars think that Tim suffered from a combination of tuberculosis and rickets. Rickets is a bone disorder caused by vitamin D deficiency. The deficiency leads to softened bones, and leg braces were used in the 1840s for this condition. Vitamin D deficiency can also contribute to tuberculosis by weakening the immune system. Tuberculosis was prevalent in Dickens’ London. Tiny Tim lived in impoverished, cramped housing and a polluted neighborhood in which coal soot blocked the sun’s ultraviolet light needed to help the body synthesize vitamin D. Sixty percent of working-class children had rickets in London during Dickens’ time. Both conditions could have been improved with sunshine, a better diet and cod liver oil.

Other scholars suggest Tim had polio, cerebral palsy or a kidney disease called renal tubular acidosis.

portrait file Dickens02

The Works of Charles Dickens

Portrait of Charles Dickens

image file Dickens03

The Works of Charles Dickens

Image of A Christmas carol

Top